machine:Machine checks passed: 2/2. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:Roma (roma.app) is a real YC-backed product with a live Mac app (v0.7.2706 downloadable .dmg), an App Store listing, and its own registered domain. The PR is by @kaminariouji, touches only files under startups/, machine checks all passed: PR by claimant, website on own domain, logo matches the site's own icon.svg (rendered from SVG to PNG, which the bounty explicitly permits as "render the site's SVG logo or use its app icon"), GitHub star confirmed. No blockers, no holds. The logo_original check passed, confirming it is genuine branding and not an upscaled small icon. The delivery meets every bullet checkable at this stage. The publication gate (stompstart.com/api/startups/roma returning the PR attribution) is the human acceptance check, not the auto-review gate.

machine:Machine checks passed: 2/2. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All seven acceptance bullets met. Receipt e516b1fa... verified by machine: Ausca published inbox.receive, $0.05, 2026-10-06T09:05:58Z, within the eligible window. Run followed the documented path exactly: bindings taken from the live 402 challenge, unsigned envelope drew the live requirement, retried with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE, inbox opened for 1 hour, real email sent from a controlled account, message retrieved and validated through the returned access authority, inbox deleted with HTTP 200. evidence_json records invocation_id paid_1f41cc8d..., output_digest sha256:f26785d9..., offer_revision_digest, and on-chain tx 0xe113b26f... at block 52244106 — independently verifiable. Twelve observations cover all required steps with elapsed milliseconds and specific identifiers. report.md walks the same steps in order with a timing table and five concrete findings: resource_access omits the address (field name, workaround, fix), lease object has two names and different shapes (verified with exact invocation id), stale idempotency key returns misleading HTTP 410 with exact error body and a specific 409 suggestion, status route shape is inconsistent, DELETE success status is undocumented. All findings are tied to exact steps with exact field names, status codes, and error text. Secrets (capability, extension_authorization) properly redacted throughout. No fabrication signals; the friction details (resource_access.address returning undefined, the 410 dead end) are the kind of specifics only a real run produces.

machine:Machine checks passed: 2/2. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All seven acceptance bullets are met with real evidence. Receipt a82dec863f44 is Ausca-published, document.analysis, $0.30, succeeded 2026-09-26T02:11 — inside the timeline and after the bounty posted. Machine floor passed both checks. evidence_json has 11 observations with step-level timing and identifiers covering every required step. report.md walks the same steps in order with matching identifiers. Six concrete findings each carry exact HTTP status, field name or error code, and a specific proposed change — finding 1 (2xx on refusal) and finding 2 (unsigned probe mints the quote, contradicting "retry the same bytes") are sharp operational discoveries only a real run would surface. Output schema validation was done with a locally written validator self-tested against a broken object; output_digest was recomputed from compact JSON and matched; chunk hash was recomputed and matched; settlement was read from Base logs, not a response header. All four slots in evidence_json and report describe the same invocation, same receipt, same tx. No fabricated artifacts, no dead URLs, no credential leaks, no misattribution. Strong 5/5 against the floor of 4.

human review:Receipt names Ausca and media document analysis, 30 cents settled 02:10:51Z inside the report timeline, invocation succeeded. 11 observations; report order and timings agree with the chain. Actionable findings: quote refs minted fresh on each probe, HTTP 200 on a refusal. One finding is wrong (the live SKILL.md has listed FORMS, TABLES, SIGNATURES, LAYOUT since 09-03); not a contract return reason.

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery