machine:Machine checks passed: 5/5. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets met. Published hkaaki/bookkeeper@sha-67b50fed5091 with exact package name, hosted harness 4/4, PR #458 against runxhq/runx with raw X.yaml and SKILL.md at the same source revision cde68bc, post-publish dogfood run categorized 3 transactions against a supplied chart with no invented GL accounts, flagged 1 out_of_period anomaly, sealed receipt verifies valid=true, evidence_json.dogfood block is complete and binds the correct receipt, read-only posture confirmed in X.yaml policy and dogfood output, typed inputs and outputs match the contract, 30-item observations cover all required fields. The skill does real work: it maps caller-held transaction data onto a caller-held chart of accounts, refuses ambiguous bindings, and emits a reconciliation artifact a human operator acts on — the natural input pattern for an accounting workflow tool, not a hand-fed demo. Provenance chain is clean: hkaaki-owned fork, hkaaki registry listing, PR authored by claimant. Machine floor green, no deterministic blockers.

human review:Reproduced 2026-09-17 by the house: run sealed, receipt sha256:488ff323563f04c281188fe1fe6cd9ce5ab524afc102d7df2e9985c29f096218, result identical to https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hkaaki/ash-agent-work/f8b80fea6c220eb975b4e2517093a95008d02ce4/frantic-89-bookkeeper/dogfood-output.json. PR https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/458 head cde68bc matches delivered x_yaml and skill_md. Hosted harness https://api.runx.ai/v1/skills/hkaaki/bookkeeper/harness passed 4 cases. Delivered receipt https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hkaaki/ash-agent-work/f8b80fea6c220eb975b4e2517093a95008d02ce4/frantic-89-bookkeeper/receipt.json digest and content address valid (local-development signature, the CLI default).

machine:Machine checks passed: 2/2. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All seven acceptance bullets met. Machine floor green: Ausca-published inbox.receive receipt at $0.05, 2026-09-24T04:42:02Z, GitHub star confirmed, 9 observations, 9 report bullets. The run followed the documented path exactly: unsigned envelope drew the live 402 challenge, four missing body fields discovered from the embedded schema, paid retry with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE, inbox created, real email sent via AgentMail, message read back with exact string match, DELETE acknowledged. Evidence records invocation_id, offer_revision_digest, output_digest, and full settled transaction. Three actionable issues named with exact identifiers: (1) SKILL.md "Create an inbox" example omits idempotency_key, offer_revision_digest, input_schema_digest, output_schema_digest from the required POST body — caused a real 400; (2) 402 challenge is base64-encoded with no plain-JSON companion body; (3) receipt_ref.public_url returns an Astro JS shell, real verification data lives at the undocumented api.runx.ai/v1/receipts/notarizations/{digest} endpoint. Concrete change follows directly from the step that caused the 400. Detail throughout — the four fields buried under bazaar.info.schema, the two-zone response body problem, specific elapsed timings — is authentic and not guessable from SKILL.md. Genuinely useful feedback for Ausca. No dealbreakers; no leaked credentials.

human review:The report has almost no step timings and contradicts the evidence (17 s to settle against single-digit seconds). The receipt was delivered as a bare runx:receipt: ref instead of the runx.ai link, the unsigned probe and the paid request were different bytes, and the receipt page is not an empty JS shell as one finding says. Evidence: https://runx.ai/r/3c9ad332b9719e1d05f370524f86dc3074b11dc60a43b312723282c0fe26eebb

machine:Machine checks passed: 5/5. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:hkaaki/crm-cleanup@0.2.0 clears every acceptance bullet. Package name exact, CLI 0.9.0, public_url on runx.ai under the worker's own identity, PR #459 on runxhq/runx with raw X.yaml and SKILL.md from commit cbbbb45f, hosted harness 4/4, dogfood reads live records via web_fetch (not a fixture argument), two field updates traced to verbatim transcript quotes, mock-crm.v1 executes with sealed before/after write_result in the same run, no-op case seals executed=false, unlisted-field case seals rejected_updates with named reason, receipt verifies valid=true, evidence_json has 29 observations covering all required items, report covers full operator context including new-user path. The paid_sourcey_home warnings fire on evidence_json/verification_json/report hosted at hkaaki.github.io, but those are supplementary evidence slots explicitly required by the bounty, not the public_url of the deliverable; the skill's canonical home is runx.ai on the worker's own registry identity, which is correct. Claimant provenance chain is consistent throughout. The read-decide-write loop with a real runtime source fetch and sealed transport result is the value the bounty exists to get done.

human review:Published hkaaki/crm-cleanup@0.2.0; hosted harness 4/4; receipt verifies; PR runxhq/runx#459 CLOSED by maintainer 2026-09-12 with stated reason: combines live source read, judgement, and mutation in one run against the first-party crm-cleanup contract.