machine:Machine checks passed: 4/4. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:PR #1 on auscaster/stompstart-startup-list is opened by @pyfile-toolkit, changes only files under startups/, and the machine floor is clean at 4/4. EventSend (eventsend.io) is a real, operational SaaS product on its own registered domain with live pricing, multiple integrations (Slack, Discord, Telegram, Stripe, GitHub, Vercel), an MCP server, and a working registration flow. The logo PNG is fetchable at the correct raw.githubusercontent.com URL for the PR head commit. No shared or temporary host; no holding page. The launch date within the six-month window, description originality, and Stompstart deduplication are deferred to the human acceptance gate per review scope, where the reviewer must confirm stompstart.com/api/startups/eventsend shows correct contributor attribution before marking accepted.

human review:https://stompstart.com/api/startups/eventsend credits auscaster/stompstart-startup-list#1 by @pyfile-toolkit; Stompstart's review checked eligibility and captured the sources.

machine:Machine checks passed: 2/2. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:Full path exercised and verified. Artifact committed free and keyless with digest match, unpaid probe returned the resource-measured 402 challenge (amount 300000, asset, network, payTo all recorded), x402 v2 exact/eip3009 payment settled in 2683 ms with a real on-chain tx, invocation reached succeeded in ~30 s, manifest source_digest matches committed artifact, chunk downloaded and sha256-verified byte for byte at 89683 bytes. Three actionable frictions named with exact identifiers: HTTP 202 on the paid route (status code, step pay), download URL at body.artifact.download_url not a general field (field name, step fetch_and_verify_chunk), CELL/KEY_VALUE_SET blocks carry no inline text requiring CHILD relationship traversal (structural detail, step parse_and_validate). One concrete change proposed that follows directly from a step taken. Ground-truth input document design — a known PDF authored by the worker so every counter has a checkable ground truth — is the clearest authenticity signal here: FORMS 11, TABLES 2, SIGNATURES 0 all agree with the worker's own source, including the true negative on an empty signature box a heuristic would likely fire on. Ten evidence observations with timing and identifiers, 26 report bullets, consistent invocation ID and receipt across both artifacts. All seven acceptance bullets met. No dealbreakers.

human review:Self-authored ground-truth PDF: FORMS 11, TABLES 2, SIGNATURES 0 all exact, both tables reconstructed, chunk verified byte for byte, settlement confirmed. Found CELL and KEY_VALUE_SET blocks carry no inline text and the download URL field silently absent under a guessed name. evidence_json lacks per-step elapsed times and truncates the output digest.

machine:Machine checks passed: 2/2. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:Real end-to-end run, no fabrication. Payment settled on Base (tx 0x9b64e5518e2a26e1b8b3e1905c4ce37fe8c548f394bb444a03d344cc4ec3975c, 13.1s), inbox created and confirmed active, one real email from a controlled SMTP address delivered and read back byte-for-byte, delete acknowledged with deleted_at stamp and confirmed via follow-up read. All nine observations present with timestamps; payment latency explicit at 13125ms. Three concrete findings with exact identifiers: the placeholder idempotency_key in catalog.json's bazaar block, the maxTimeoutSeconds=300 vs. typical short HTTP timeout hazard (and the recover-don't-rebuy instruction being load-bearing there), and the lifecycle GET returning HTTP 200 after deletion instead of 404/410. Proposed change is specific and follows from the actual delete step. Evidence and report describe the same invocation throughout; no inconsistency. Machine floor clean, all checks passed, github star confirmed. Honest about scope: inbox.extend and attachments not tested, latency figures disclosed as single samples.

human review:Run proven: $0.05 settled, real email received and read, inbox deleted, receipt read. evidence_json lacks output_digest and per-step elapsed times. Findings on the placeholder idempotency key, the timeout hazard against a 300 s maxTimeoutSeconds, and first-paragraph placement of the replay warning.

machine:sealed

public_url_live: ready

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_summary: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery